Agree. "The Doctor's Wife" wins, hands down. It has some of the best quotes in the new series, in my opinion. "I like biting! It's like kissing, only there's a winner!" "What makes you think I'd ever give you back?" Also, it has House messing with Rory and Amy.
I have problems with "The Girl Who Waited" based in Older Amy's complete lack of logic (not her desire to live, that makes sense, but lack of logic in other things), but otherwise I really like the episode.
And yeah, "A Good Man Goes to War" should be a better episode than it is. It's a good episode! But not everything it promised. And its "big reveal" was something I'd suspected for a long while. (Though, I have to say, I didn't catch the name thing until it was pointed out.) I don't feel the "finest moment and his darkest" thing, either. I feel like he's been through worse? And accomplished better (and with fewer allies)? And why should either of thsoe moments of his center around his Companion? (Especially Amy, but I've never been a fan of Amy, so that's probably my bias speaking. Bring back Donna! LOVE DONNA. DONNAAAAAA!!!!)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2012-04-30 01:53 pm (UTC)I have problems with "The Girl Who Waited" based in Older Amy's complete lack of logic (not her desire to live, that makes sense, but lack of logic in other things), but otherwise I really like the episode.
And yeah, "A Good Man Goes to War" should be a better episode than it is. It's a good episode! But not everything it promised. And its "big reveal" was something I'd suspected for a long while. (Though, I have to say, I didn't catch the name thing until it was pointed out.) I don't feel the "finest moment and his darkest" thing, either. I feel like he's been through worse? And accomplished better (and with fewer allies)? And why should either of thsoe moments of his center around his Companion? (Especially Amy, but I've never been a fan of Amy, so that's probably my bias speaking. Bring back Donna! LOVE DONNA. DONNAAAAAA!!!!)